• 0 Posts
  • 48 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 28th, 2024

help-circle
  • I never claimed to know what you know.

    I just hoped that if you did know more, you’d be horrified by a lot more than just “the last several years”. That’s all I meant with my first comment. And since you claim to know so much, I’m disappointed that you’re not.

    If I’m so wrong in my knowledge, then please, go ahead and correct me. I’m open to being wrong and corrected, but you’ve pointed out nothing where I am in fact wrong.

    Because in my understanding, it is factual that Zionist militias were operating in the 1920s (100+ years ago!), 1930s (most of the action was after the Arab Revolt in 1936), and 1940s until the state of Israel was formed, after which they were dissolved and mixed into the IDF. I haven’t made claims beyond that in this thread.



  • It’s not really that complicated.

    The “over 2000 years ago” or whatever previous maybe exigent state of Israel has nothing to do with the current one, other than as a religious fig leaf and excuse for Zionism. To quote Ilan Pape: “Most Zionists don’t believe that God exists but they do believe that he promised them Palestine”

    You’re the one that brought up WW2 as a time period in the first place. Only to discard the evidence I presented of yes, in fact Zionists (who ended up forming Israel, and Zionism continues to be the basis of Israeli society and politics) were already committing what would/could/should be considered terrorist attacks against Palestinians.

    As long as Zionism/Zionists have existed in Palestine, they have existed to displace or kill all Palestinians.

    I draw the line at the most logical place: Zionism’s creation/popularization. It is the root cause of all this.


  • Not important to current events? Explain to me how groups that were merged together to form the IDF, and were fighting to create Israel is unimportant to Israel and its current actions and existence.

    From the very beginning of Zionist migration to Palestine (the historic region, whether it was under Ottoman rule or British rule), it was colonial, and intended to remove the people currently living there. You can read it from Theodore Herzl, and Ze’ev Jabotinsky. Some of the first and very prominent Zionists. David Ben-Gurion,the first prime minister of Israel himself, in a letter to his son basically said the partition plan was just the first step to taking the entire land.

    Without that ideology and attitude, we wouldn’t be where we are now.







  • Don’t have an “official” diagnosis, am probably (almost certainly) not ADHD. Almost certainly autistic. My therapist seems to agree (among other people) but can’t give me a diagnosis officially or say yes officially, but it’s treating me as if I am and it’s validating.

    Probably won’t get an official diagnosis though, there are no real treatments for it, and if I ever want to move abroad, it’ll add a lot of additional hurdles. I still struggle to say I’m autistic (because it’s not official).









  • I was mostly responding to the comment of “The israeli population is not committing genocide”, because as you say, Palestinian dehumanization and hatred is widespread. I do not claim that it’s every single person, but it’s high enough for me that it’s obviously a vanishingly small, practically insignificant minority that isn’t supportive of genocide.

    I can’t think of the last time an oppressed group successfully politely asked their oppressors to stop and had it work.

    Diplomacy has been tried repeatedly, and has never been done in good faith by Israel or Zionists. When diplomacy and peaceful protest fails, what other options are left?

    Even Colombia’s president said that he wants to put together a unified military of the world to stop the genocide by force, and I agree with that notion. It’s long past due.

    (I am, for the record, Palestinian in diaspora)



  • Not really a contradiction if you understand Zionism. Paraphrasing Theodor Herzl (recognized as one of the “founding fathers” of Zionism) “the anti-semites will become our greatest allies” in the late 1800s

    Because anti-Semites would support Jewish emigration. White supremacists and neo Nazis would be glad to see them gone from the US. And they have an easy place to push them.

    That, and Israel’s importance today to US government is more about geopolitics and power projection than about ethnic/religious identity.

    And also the Christian zionist angle other people have mentioned with Armageddon.